MAN Asian Musings


January 6, 2013 by markstani

The fifteen longlisted titles for this year’s MAN Asian Literary Prize have taken the reader on a memorable ride from the wild north-west of Pakistan through Mumbai opium dens and Saudi goat farms. They have stretched beyond continental boundaries to reach the rolling Italian countryside, the East End of London and Mexico’s remote Yucatan peninsula.
All told, I’d say it’s been a fairly impressive year, and having read thirteen (plus two halves) of the listed titles, I can honestly say there was only one whose merits completely passed me by. As I hoped, I discovered a number of new authors whose next work I await with interest.
My thoughts below are not meant as any kind of definitive judgement. As part of the ‘Shadow’ Prize jury, I’ll be liaising with my fellow jurors to determine a winner from the titles that make the official shortlist. Who knows where our collective opinion will lead us? For what it’s worth, here’s my idea of the ideal shortlist:

NORTHERN GIRLS: In Qian Xiaohong, author Sheng Keyi has created a captivating central character whom it is impossible not to root for on every inch of her journey from remote Hunan province to the slutty Chinese city of Shenzen.

THINNER THAN SKIN: An epic in every sense of the word, Uzma Aslam Khan weaves a bewitching tale of revenge and forgiveness set in the ruggedly beautiful but terror-stricken lands of north-west Pakistan.

: It seems a long time since Jeet Thayil’s story about Mumbai opium dens was first flagged up as a potential Prize contender. But there’s good reason why it’s one of the favourites. It’s an audacious and compellingly addictive novel.

: This is a remarkable feat for a first novel. Nayomi Munaweera blends the beauty of Sri Lankan life with the horrors of its civil war to quite brilliant effect. Definitely a name to watch out for for.

RU: At just 153 pages, Kim Thuy’s ‘Ru’ is a slip of a book but it certainly packs a punch. A series of vignettes revolving around a family’s emigration from Vietnam to Canada, it unfurls into something quite riveting.

BETWEEN CLAY AND DUST: Musharraf Ali Farooqi crafts an affecting tale of an old Pakistani wrestler struggling to come to terms with societal changes which increasingly render his achievements a relic of a bygone age.

Of the remaining titles, I wouldn’t begrudge a shortlist place for Roma Tearne’s highly readable The Road To Urbino, Benyamin’s memorable Goat Days, Elif Shafak’s ingeniously structured Honour or Hiromi Kawakami’s subtle and understated THE BRIEFCASE (which I will review in conjunction with a number of other bloggers at the end of the month).
Two titles have so far eluded me: I’m halfway through Tie Ning’s THE BATHING WOMEN, which is evolving into something reasonably promising after a rocky start, and Tan Twan Eng’s much-feted THE GARDEN OF EVENING MISTS, which I have to admit, left me pretty cold and prompted a temporary abandonment before the halfway stage.
Of the remaining titles, there was plenty to admire in Orhan Pamuk’s Silent House, but I felt it dragged in places, and I’m not entirely sure what it would say about the current state of Asian literature if the Prize went to a thirty-year-old book by a Nobel prize winner. Although I found the story fascinating, I was generally disappointed by Young-ha Kim’s story of Korean emigrants to Mexico, Black Flower, which I found rather cold and clinical, and the least said about Anjali Joseph’s Another Country, the better.

6 thoughts on “MAN Asian Musings

  1. I was hoping someone would write a round up after tackling all of them. I rather liked The Garden of Evening Mists after reading it when it was listed for Man Booker but rather unusually I found myself wondering if it was as good as I thought a month or two later. Normally I am more likely to revise my score up than down. I think it benefitted from reading it all in a day or two and I suspect it was the whole I enjoyed, when I look back at the characters and the specifics of the plot I am not sure it holds up to a second read or close scrutiny.

  2. markbooks says:

    Thanks Alex. I’m sure I’ll get round to giving it another try. One thing that surprised me about this list is how many of the really good ones – three of my top four, in fact – haven’t yet got UK publishing deals. Hopefully if they reach the shortlist things will change…

  3. Kimchi says:

    Man Asian Literary Prize short list (my forecast):
    Tie Ning, Jeet Thayil, Tan Twan Eng, Elif Shafak, Uzma Aslam Khan, Kim Thuy
    little chance for Musharraf Ali Farooqi (alternative to Uzma).

    Man Asian Literary Prize short list (If I’m the judge -according to my taste-):
    Tie Ning, Tan Twan Eng, Elif Shafak, Sheng Keyi
    and as 5’th Musharraf Ali Farooqi or Benjamin

  4. markbooks says:

    The great thing about this year’s list is I couldn’t really argue too much with either of those. Although I won’t hide my disappointment if Northern Girls and/or Thinner Than Skin don’t make it…

  5. winstonsdad says:

    sounds like fair list ones I ve read that there agree with ,all the best stu

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: