Thoughts: MAN Asian Literary Prize


March 15, 2012 by markstani

Kyung-sook Shin’s Please Look After Mother has won the MAN Asian Literary Prize for 2011. I’m pleased with the result, though I know of others who aren’t. It’s fair to say the book polarised opinion among the blogging community more than any of the other six shortlisted contenders.
Whatever your view, I don’t think anybody can deny the impression ‘Please Look After Mother’ has made on the Asian literary scene. It has sold well over one million copies in South Korea, and been translated into many different languages. That might not justify its Prize-winning in itself, but it certainly underlines its popularity.
‘Please Look After Mother’ was also voted our ‘Shadow’ Jury winner, and Shin’s Prize horde might not stop there: it’s been longlisted for this year’s Independent Foreign Fiction Prize.
Overall, I think this year saw a particularly strong longlist. It is testament to the quality of those that made the cut that you couldn’t argue too loudly with the omission of two excellent novels, The Folded Earth and The Good Muslim, from the shortlist.
Of the remaining seven, only Banana Yoshimoto’s The Lake jarred a little for me, though it was by no means bad enough to put me off Yoshimoto for life: on the contrary, I’ll look her next book up out of interest.
I’ve said before that I though Jamil Ahmad’s The Wandering Falcon was the best of the lot. His book deserves to be read, if only to shatter the convenient myths associated with the so-called Pakistani tribal areas. I was delighted to see a bunch of his books in Harrogate Waterstone’s recently. Nobody can deny that Prizes such as the MAN Asian Literary Prize help spread the word about worthy reads.
For much the same reason, I’d like to mention Rebirth by Jahnavi Barua – the only shortlisted title whose publication was restricted to the Indian subcontinent. Her delicate tale of love and loss in Assam and Bangalore was worth tracking down, and if the result of its spotlighting is that Barua goes on to gain global rights, then this year’s Prize will have its ideal legacy.


3 thoughts on “Thoughts: MAN Asian Literary Prize

  1. Harvee says:

    The book, Please Look After Mother, broke my heart, and I'm glad it was fiction and not a real story. But it does show family dynamics in South Korea and I am sure reflects other countries as well. I do believe it deserved the prize. I also liked River of Smoke, another book I believe was nominated.

  2. The Folded Earth and The Good Muslim are both high in my TBR pile so I'm pleased to see that you rate them so highly. I was very impressed by The Wandering Falcon and I look forward to reading Please Look After Mother. I do love this prize!

  3. Like you thoughts Mark … And your new look. While I did rank Shin first, my rankings were all pretty close and I had a gut feeling Falcon was going to win. I wouldn't have been sorry if it had … It was a strong list I agree and so hard in the end to choose.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: